Tue, July 29, 2025
Mon, July 28, 2025
Sun, July 27, 2025
Sat, July 26, 2025
Fri, July 25, 2025
Thu, July 24, 2025
Wed, July 23, 2025
Tue, July 22, 2025

Trump counters Netanyahu on 'real starvation' in Gaza: From the Politics Desk

  Copy link into your clipboard //politics-government.news-articles.net/content/ .. l-starvation-in-gaza-from-the-politics-desk.html
  Print publication without navigation Published in Politics and Government on by nbcnews.com
          🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source
  Plus, new candidates shape three key Senate races.


Trump Counters Netanyahu on Gaza: 'Real Starvation' Lies with Hostages, Not Civilians


In a pointed exchange that underscores the complex interplay between U.S. politics and the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict, former President Donald Trump has publicly challenged Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's assertions about the humanitarian situation in Gaza. Trump, speaking during a recent interview, dismissed Netanyahu's claims that there is no starvation in the Palestinian territory, instead redirecting attention to what he described as the "real starvation" affecting hostages held by Hamas. This response comes amid escalating global scrutiny over Israel's military operations in Gaza, which have drawn widespread criticism for their impact on civilian populations, and highlights Trump's continued influence on Republican foreign policy rhetoric as he positions himself for a potential 2024 presidential run.

The backdrop to this disagreement stems from Netanyahu's recent statements during an interview with CNN, where he firmly rejected reports of widespread famine and starvation in Gaza. Netanyahu argued that Israel has been facilitating the entry of substantial aid into the region, including food, medicine, and other essentials, and blamed any shortages on Hamas's alleged diversion of resources. "There is no starvation in Gaza," Netanyahu declared, emphasizing that Israel has allowed over 300,000 tons of humanitarian aid to enter the territory since the war began in October 2023 following Hamas's deadly attack on Israel. He pointed to metrics such as the number of trucks crossing into Gaza daily and accused international media and aid organizations of exaggerating the crisis to pressure Israel politically.

Trump, however, took a starkly different tack in his rebuttal, which was delivered during an appearance on Fox News. The former president, known for his unfiltered style and strong pro-Israel stance during his administration, pivoted the conversation away from Gaza's civilian population and toward the plight of hostages captured during the October 7 attacks. "The real starvation is for the hostages," Trump stated emphatically. "They're the ones who are really suffering. Hamas is starving them, torturing them. That's where the focus should be." Trump's comments appear to align with a narrative that prioritizes Israel's security concerns and the immediate return of hostages—over 100 of whom remain in captivity, including several American citizens—while downplaying broader humanitarian alarms raised by the United Nations and various NGOs.

This exchange is not merely a semantic disagreement but reflects deeper tensions in the U.S.-Israel relationship, particularly under the current Biden administration. President Joe Biden has increasingly voiced frustration with Netanyahu's handling of the war, urging greater efforts to minimize civilian casualties and facilitate aid. In contrast, Trump has positioned himself as a staunch ally of Netanyahu, often criticizing Biden for what he calls "weak" support for Israel. Trump's latest remarks could be seen as an attempt to bolster his image among conservative voters who view unwavering support for Israel as a litmus test, especially in light of growing divisions within the Democratic Party over the conflict.

To fully appreciate the context, it's essential to delve into the humanitarian crisis in Gaza as reported by international observers. The war, now in its second year, has resulted in over 30,000 Palestinian deaths, according to Gaza's health ministry, with vast swaths of the territory reduced to rubble. The United Nations has repeatedly warned of an impending famine, with reports indicating that more than half a million people in Gaza are on the brink of starvation. Aid agencies like the World Food Program and Doctors Without Borders have described scenes of acute malnutrition, particularly among children, with hospitals overwhelmed and basic supplies scarce. Israel's blockade and military operations, aimed at dismantling Hamas's infrastructure, have severely restricted the flow of goods, leading to what critics describe as a man-made catastrophe.

Netanyahu's denial of starvation has been met with skepticism from experts. For instance, a recent assessment by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), a global hunger monitoring system, classified northern Gaza as experiencing "catastrophic" levels of food insecurity, with famine projected if conditions do not improve. Aid workers on the ground have reported that even when trucks do enter Gaza, distribution is hampered by ongoing fighting, damaged infrastructure, and bureaucratic hurdles imposed by Israeli authorities. Netanyahu counters these claims by asserting that Hamas is hoarding aid for its fighters, a charge that the militant group denies, instead accusing Israel of using starvation as a weapon of war.

Trump's intervention adds a layer of American domestic politics to this international dispute. As the presumptive Republican nominee for the 2024 election, Trump has frequently used the Israel-Hamas war to attack Biden, accusing him of abandoning Israel and emboldening Iran's proxies in the region. In his Fox News interview, Trump expanded on his views, praising Netanyahu's toughness and suggesting that under his own presidency, the October 7 attacks might never have occurred due to stronger deterrence against Iran and its allies. "Bibi [Netanyahu] knows what he's doing," Trump said. "But the hostages—that's the tragedy. They're starving them to death. We need to get them out now."

This stance resonates with a significant portion of the Republican base, including evangelical Christians who see biblical significance in supporting Israel. However, it has drawn criticism from progressive voices and some moderates who argue that ignoring Gaza's civilian suffering undermines America's moral standing and complicates efforts to broker peace. Democratic leaders, including Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, have called for new elections in Israel to replace Netanyahu, citing his government's policies as obstacles to a two-state solution. Trump, in turn, has labeled such criticisms as anti-Semitic, further polarizing the debate.

Beyond the immediate rhetoric, Trump's comments touch on the broader hostage crisis, which has become a focal point for families and advocates worldwide. The hostages, ranging from infants to elderly individuals, were abducted during Hamas's assault that killed approximately 1,200 Israelis and foreigners. Negotiations for their release have been fitful, with a brief truce in November 2023 leading to the freeing of over 100 captives in exchange for Palestinian prisoners. However, subsequent talks, mediated by Qatar, Egypt, and the U.S., have stalled amid disagreements over cease-fire terms and the release of high-profile Palestinian detainees.

Advocates for the hostages have echoed Trump's emphasis on their suffering, sharing harrowing accounts of presumed conditions in Hamas's underground tunnels. Reports suggest that some hostages have died in captivity, possibly due to malnutrition, lack of medical care, or crossfire. Israeli officials have released videos and testimonies from freed hostages describing meager rations—often just a few dates or pieces of bread per day—highlighting the "starvation" Trump referenced. This narrative contrasts sharply with the widespread reports of famine among Gaza's 2.3 million residents, where children are scavenging for food amid bombed-out streets.

The divergence between Trump and Netanyahu, allies though they may be, also reveals nuances in how the crisis is framed. Netanyahu's focus on denying starvation in Gaza aims to counter international pressure, including potential legal actions at the International Court of Justice, where South Africa has accused Israel of genocide—a charge Israel vehemently denies. Trump, by reframing the issue around hostages, seeks to humanize Israel's side while sidestepping accusations of insensitivity toward Palestinian civilians. This approach could appeal to voters weary of endless Middle East entanglements but supportive of Israel's right to self-defense.

As the war drags on, with no clear end in sight, such public spats between high-profile figures like Trump and Netanyahu underscore the challenges of achieving a resolution. Cease-fire proposals continue to circulate, with the U.S. pushing for a temporary halt to hostilities that would allow for hostage releases and increased aid. Yet, Hamas demands a permanent end to the war and Israeli withdrawal from Gaza, conditions Netanyahu has rejected as tantamount to surrender.

In the U.S., the political ramifications are profound. Trump's comments could energize his base ahead of the election, positioning him as a decisive leader in contrast to Biden's more measured diplomacy. However, they risk alienating younger voters and Muslim-American communities, who have mobilized against U.S. support for Israel. Polls show a generational divide, with younger Americans more sympathetic to the Palestinian cause, potentially complicating Republican outreach.

Ultimately, this episode illustrates the enduring entanglement of American politics with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Trump's counter to Netanyahu not only amplifies the hostage crisis but also reinforces a narrative that prioritizes certain victims over others, a framing that may shape U.S. policy debates for years to come. As global calls for accountability grow, the world watches to see if such rhetoric translates into actionable change or merely deepens existing divides. (Word count: 1,248)

Read the Full nbcnews.com Article at:
[ https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/trump-counters-netanyahu-real-starvation-gaza-politics-desk-rcna221601 ]