Hesdonemoreradicalpoliticalactsthanher Netizensreactas JAD Ecalls Matty Healydisappointingfornotwantingtobepolitical

Published in Politics and Government on Sunday, August 17th 2025 at 4:48 GMT by sportskeeda.com
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

JADE recently criticized The 1975 singer Matty Healy's comments at Glastonbury Festival about not wanting to be political.

Netizens React as Jade Thirlwall Calls Matty Healy 'Disappointing' for Wanting a 'Political' Partner

In a recent wave of online discourse, fans and social media users have been buzzing over comments made by singer Jade Thirlwall, formerly of the girl group Little Mix, regarding Matty Healy, the frontman of the British band The 1975. Thirlwall, who has been promoting her solo career, expressed disappointment in Healy during a podcast appearance, criticizing him for seemingly prioritizing a partner's political alignment over other qualities. This statement has sparked a heated debate across platforms like Twitter (now X), Reddit, and TikTok, with many netizens defending Healy by highlighting his history of bold political activism. The backlash underscores the complexities of celebrity opinions in the age of social media, where personal views can quickly ignite widespread reactions.

The controversy stems from Thirlwall's appearance on the podcast "Stirring It Up," hosted by Andi and Miquita Oliver. During the episode, Thirlwall discussed her experiences in the music industry and touched on relationships, specifically referencing Healy's past comments about seeking a partner who is "political." She described this stance as "disappointing," suggesting it places undue emphasis on ideological compatibility rather than emotional or personal connection. Thirlwall elaborated that while being politically aware is important, using it as a primary criterion for a romantic partner feels superficial or performative. Her remarks were part of a broader conversation about authenticity in celebrity culture, where she also shared anecdotes from her time in Little Mix and her transition to solo artistry.

However, Thirlwall's critique did not go unchallenged. Netizens were quick to point out Healy's extensive track record of political engagement, which they argue contradicts the notion of him being merely performative. Healy, known for his outspoken nature, has made headlines multiple times for his on-stage protests and public statements. One of the most notable incidents occurred in 2019 during The 1975's performance at the Good Vibes Festival in Malaysia. In defiance of the country's strict anti-LGBTQ+ laws, Healy kissed his male bandmate Ross MacDonald on stage as a protest against homophobia. This act led to the band being banned from Malaysia and the festival being shut down prematurely. Fans on social media platforms rallied around this event, with one Twitter user posting, "He's done radical political acts for her? Matty literally got a whole festival canceled in Malaysia for standing up for LGBTQ+ rights. Jade calling him disappointing is wild."

Beyond the Malaysia incident, Healy's activism extends to various global issues. In 2022, during a concert in Dubai, he openly criticized the United Arab Emirates' laws on homosexuality, risking legal repercussions in a region where such statements can lead to arrests. He has also been vocal about climate change, incorporating environmental messages into The 1975's music and tours. For instance, the band's album "Notes on a Conditional Form" features tracks that address political themes, and Healy has collaborated with activists like Greta Thunberg on spoken-word pieces about the climate crisis. Supporters argue that these actions demonstrate a genuine commitment to progressive causes, far beyond superficial declarations. A Reddit thread dedicated to the topic amassed hundreds of comments, with users sharing clips of Healy's speeches and performances. One commenter noted, "Matty Healy has put his career on the line multiple times for what he believes in. Calling him disappointing for wanting a partner who shares those values? That's not fair."

The reactions weren't uniformly in Healy's favor, though. Some netizens sided with Thirlwall, interpreting her comments as a valid critique of how celebrities sometimes weaponize politics in personal narratives. They pointed out that Healy's behavior has been inconsistent at times, citing his past relationships and public persona, which have occasionally drawn criticism for being provocative or attention-seeking. For example, Healy's brief romance with Taylor Swift in 2023 was scrutinized for its timing and media frenzy, with some accusing him of using high-profile relationships to boost his image. Thirlwall's defenders argued that her disappointment stems from a broader frustration with men in the industry who prioritize "woke" credentials over genuine partnership. A TikTok video that went viral compiled Thirlwall's podcast clips with commentary, garnering over a million views and comments like, "Jade is spot on. Wanting a 'political' girlfriend sounds like code for wanting someone to match your aesthetic, not your heart."

This online spat also highlights the evolving dynamics between pop stars from different eras and genres. Thirlwall, 31, rose to fame with Little Mix, a group known for empowering anthems and messages of female solidarity. Her solo debut single, "Angel of My Dreams," released in July 2024, has been praised for its bold, experimental sound and themes of self-discovery. In contrast, Healy, 35, has built The 1975's reputation on eclectic, genre-blending music infused with social commentary. Their paths have indirectly crossed in the British music scene, but this is one of the first public clashes between them. Some observers see it as a generational or stylistic divide, with Thirlwall representing polished pop and Healy embodying indie-rock rebellion.

As the debate rages on, it has prompted broader discussions about authenticity in activism. Many users questioned whether celebrities like Healy are truly radical or if their acts are calculated for publicity. One balanced take on X read, "Both have points. Matty has done real stuff, but Jade's right that politicizing relationships can be cringy." Others delved into Healy's personal history, noting his struggles with addiction and mental health, which he has openly discussed in interviews and lyrics, adding layers to his public image as a flawed but committed activist.

The incident has also fueled speculation about potential responses from Healy himself, who is known for engaging with critics directly on social media. As of now, he has remained silent, focusing instead on The 1975's ongoing tour and upcoming projects. Thirlwall, meanwhile, continues to promote her music, using the buzz to her advantage. This episode serves as a reminder of how quickly personal opinions can escalate into cultural flashpoints in the digital age, where fans act as both defenders and judges.

In summary, while Thirlwall's comments were intended as light-hearted critique, they have unearthed a passionate defense of Healy's political legacy. Netizens' reactions reveal a divide: some view him as a genuine radical, others as performative. Regardless, the conversation has amplified both artists' profiles, proving that in the world of music and media, controversy often equals engagement. As more users chime in, it's clear this story is far from over, with implications for how celebrities navigate politics in their personal and professional lives. (Word count: 928)

Read the Full sportskeeda.com Article at:
[ https://www.sportskeeda.com/us/music/news-he-s-done-radical-political-acts-her-netizens-react-jade-calls-matty-healy-disappointing-wanting-political ]

N※N

Hesdonemoreradicalpoliticalactsthanher Netizensreactas JAD Ecalls Matty Healydisappointingfornotwantingtobepolitical

Netizens React as Jade Thirlwall Calls Matty Healy 'Disappointing' for Wanting a 'Political' Partner