N※N

Show Politics and Government Publications

Israeli Coalition Government Faces Crisis as Key Ally Withdraws

In a significant political development in Israel, another key ally of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has withdrawn from the governing coalition, leaving Netanyahu with a minority in the Israeli parliament, known as the Knesset. This departure marks a critical blow to Netanyahu’s hold on power, further destabilizing an already fragile coalition that has been grappling with internal divisions and external pressures. The exit of this ally, whose identity and specific reasons for leaving are tied to broader discontent within the coalition, underscores the deepening political crisis in Israel, a country that has faced repeated elections and governmental instability in recent years.

The coalition, which was initially formed as a broad and diverse alliance of parties united primarily by their opposition to Netanyahu’s long tenure as prime minister, has been fraying at the seams for months. This alliance, comprising parties from across the political spectrum—including right-wing, centrist, and even an Arab Islamist faction—came together in 2021 to oust Netanyahu after over a decade of his leadership. However, the coalition’s inherent ideological differences have made governance challenging, with frequent disagreements over policy issues ranging from security and settlements to economic reforms and the role of religion in public life. The departure of this latest ally is a culmination of these tensions, reflecting the difficulty of maintaining unity in a coalition that was always more of a marriage of convenience than a partnership of shared vision.

The specific trigger for this resignation appears to be rooted in dissatisfaction with the coalition’s direction under the leadership of Prime Minister Naftali Bennett and Foreign Minister Yair Lapid, who have been rotating the premiership as part of a power-sharing agreement. The departing member, whose party or faction held critical seats in the Knesset, reportedly felt sidelined or disagreed with key decisions, particularly on matters related to Israel’s policies in the occupied West Bank or budgetary allocations that may have favored other coalition partners. This exit is not an isolated event but rather part of a pattern of defections and resignations that have plagued the coalition since its inception. Earlier defections had already reduced the coalition’s majority, and with this latest departure, the government no longer commands the 61 seats needed for a majority in the 120-seat Knesset, placing it in a precarious minority position.

The implications of this development are profound for Israeli politics. A minority government is inherently unstable, as it lacks the votes to pass legislation or fend off no-confidence motions without relying on opposition support—a scenario that is unlikely given the polarized nature of Israeli politics. Netanyahu, now the leader of the opposition and head of the Likud party, has been quick to capitalize on this vulnerability. He has repeatedly called for the dissolution of the current government and the holding of new elections, which would be Israel’s fifth in less than four years. Netanyahu’s political career, though marred by ongoing corruption trials, remains a powerful force in Israeli politics, and he has been actively working to rally his base and exploit the coalition’s weaknesses. The loss of a parliamentary majority for the current government plays directly into his hands, as it increases the likelihood of a return to power for the veteran politician who has dominated Israeli politics for much of the past two decades.

For the coalition, the immediate challenge is survival. Leaders like Bennett and Lapid must now navigate a delicate balancing act to keep the government afloat. This could involve negotiations with independent lawmakers or smaller factions outside the coalition to secure ad hoc support for critical votes. However, such arrangements are tenuous at best and could further erode the coalition’s credibility among the Israeli public, many of whom are already frustrated with the cycle of political deadlock and repeated elections. There is also the possibility that the coalition could collapse entirely if more members defect or if a no-confidence vote succeeds in the Knesset. In such a scenario, Israel would likely head to yet another election, a prospect that many citizens view with exasperation given the lack of decisive outcomes in previous rounds of voting.

Beyond the immediate political ramifications, this crisis reflects deeper structural issues within Israel’s political system. The country’s proportional representation electoral system often results in fragmented parliaments where no single party can secure a clear majority, necessitating coalitions that are prone to infighting and collapse. This systemic issue has been exacerbated by the personal and ideological rivalries that define much of Israeli politics today, particularly the polarizing figure of Netanyahu, who remains a lightning rod for both fervent support and intense opposition. The inability to form stable governments has also hampered Israel’s ability to address pressing challenges, including security threats, economic inequality, and the ongoing conflict with the Palestinians, which continues to simmer in the background of domestic political struggles.

The departure of this coalition ally also raises questions about the future of specific policy initiatives that the government had been pursuing. For instance, efforts to pass a state budget—a critical piece of legislation that has been delayed due to political wrangling—could be further stalled, potentially triggering automatic elections under Israeli law if a budget is not approved by a certain deadline. Additionally, policies related to settlement expansion in the West Bank, a contentious issue that divides coalition members, may face renewed scrutiny or paralysis as the government struggles to maintain cohesion. The inclusion of an Arab party in the coalition, a historic first, had been seen as a potential step toward greater inclusion and dialogue, but the current instability threatens to undermine any progress on that front as well.

From an international perspective, the political uncertainty in Israel could have ripple effects. Israel remains a key player in the Middle East, with significant influence on issues like the Iran nuclear deal, regional security dynamics, and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. A weakened or caretaker government may struggle to project strength or make bold diplomatic moves at a time when the region is navigating complex challenges, including tensions with Iran and the normalization of ties with some Arab states under the Abraham Accords. Allies like the United States, which has historically relied on a stable Israel as a cornerstone of its Middle East policy, may also be concerned about the potential for prolonged political paralysis in Jerusalem.

For the Israeli public, the unfolding crisis is yet another chapter in a seemingly endless saga of political dysfunction. Public trust in political institutions has been eroded by years of gridlock, and there is a growing sense of fatigue among voters who have been called to the polls repeatedly with little to show for it in terms of stable governance. While some Israelis may welcome the possibility of Netanyahu’s return, others fear that it would deepen divisions and entrench a leadership style that many view as divisive and self-serving. Conversely, the current coalition, despite its flaws, has been seen by some as a necessary experiment in breaking the cycle of Netanyahu’s dominance, even if it has struggled to deliver on its promises.

In conclusion, the resignation of another ally from Israel’s governing coalition marks a turning point that could precipitate the fall of the current government and usher in a new phase of political uncertainty. With Netanyahu waiting in the wings and the coalition now in a minority position, the coming weeks will be critical in determining whether the government can survive or if Israel will once again head to the polls. This crisis is not just about the immediate balance of power in the Knesset but also about the broader challenges of governance, unity, and stability in a deeply divided society. As events unfold, the stakes could not be higher for Israel’s future, both domestically and on the world stage, as it grapples with the question of how to move forward in the face of persistent political turmoil.

Read the Full PBS Article at:
[ https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/another-netanyahu-ally-quits-governing-coalition-leaving-israeli-leader-with-minority-in-parliament ]